Skip to main content

Great Nicobar Files: Development, Democracy and the “Remote Control” Raj

 

Between April 26 and 28, 2026, the Andaman & Nicobar Islands became the stage for a story that had everything politics, environment, bureaucracy, and a fair dose of desi irony. The visit of Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi was not just a routine political tour; it was the continuation of a promise made earlier when a delegation of Nicobarese tribal representatives met him in Delhi. Their concern was clear: the Great Nicobar Project might bring “development,” but at the cost of their zameen, jungle, and zindagi.

Rahul Gandhi assured them he would visit the islands and understand the situation firsthand. True to that, he arrived. But as always, in our system, kahani itni seedhi nahi hoti.


On the very first day in Port Blair, during a party convention, Rahul directly targeted the functioning of the administration. Referring to the Lieutenant Governor Devendra Kumar Joshi, he remarked that governance here seemed to be run by a “remote control,” and that remote, he said, was in the hands of Amit Shah.

Strong words, but the situation added its own layer of satire. The Lt. Governor effectively the highest authority in the islands was not even present during the visit. He was reportedly in Jammu & Kashmir attending a Chintan Shivir. As they say, “ghar pe mehmaan aur malik tour pe” perfect timing, or just another coincidence?

Then came the familiar Indian episode -permissions. Despite holding a status equivalent to a Cabinet Minister, Rahul Gandhi’s visit to Great Nicobar Island did not come easy. Approvals were delayed, processes took their own course, and the system moved at its usual pace dheere dheere, file by file.

Addressing party workers, Rahul responded with a line that quickly caught attention: “If I am not allowed, I will come again and again, baar-baar aaunga.”

The crowd cheered, but the underlying question remained serious if reaching a part of one’s own country requires this level of clearance, then what does an ordinary citizen go through?


Eventually, he did reach Great Nicobar. There, he interacted with settlers, local residents, and communities, including those concerned about displacement. Later, he shared a video from inside the rainforest, calling it one of the most extraordinary forests he had ever seen. It was less of a political statement and more of a direct observation , yeh jungle sirf jungle nahi hai, yeh ek jeeta-jaagta ecosystem hai.

And that brings us to the core issue. On paper, the Great Nicobar Project is ambitious and strategic, a transshipment port, an international airport, power infrastructure, and a large township. It is positioned as India’s gateway to global maritime trade, a bold step toward economic growth.

But on the ground, the story sounds different. The project area includes dense rainforests and regions inhabited by indigenous communities such as the Shompen. For them, the concern is not ideology; it is existence. “Development ho, lekin humare bina kaise?”  a simple question, but one without an easy answer.

Another interesting chapter of this visit was what many called the “silence factor.” While several national platforms and social media spaces discussed and shared updates about the visit, certain sections of mainstream media appeared noticeably quiet. The term “godi media” was once again whispered in conversations.


At the local level, the silence was even more striking. The Daily Telegrams, widely seen as the administration’s official newspaper, did not report the visit at all. A national political figure visits, raises major concerns, sparks debate and yet, complete blackout. As some would say, “jab control upar se ho, toh news bhi filter hokar aati hai.”

Adding to the sequence of events, helicopter services to the Nicobar Islands were suspended until May 1, officially due to aviation safety protocols under a NOTAM. Technically valid, no doubt. But once again, the timing raised eyebrows. “Sab kuch rule ke hisaab se hai… par timing thodi filmi lagti hai,” as people casually remarked.

In the end, this was more than just a political visit. It reflected a larger pattern  where big decisions are made at the top, implementation moves swiftly, but local voices often struggle to find equal space.

Rahul Gandhi highlighted concerns. The government continues to push its strategic vision. But somewhere in between, the people of the islands  and their environment  remain at the centre of a debate that is far from over.

As many would quietly put it:

“Development zaroori hai… lekin jab jungle, zameen aur pehchaan daav par ho, toh sawaal uthna bhi zaroori hai.”

The forests still stand. The communities still wait.

Aur kahani abhi khatam nahi hui hai.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Zubair Ahmed: The Voice That Echoed the Soul of the Andamans

 In the tranquil yet vibrant tapestry of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Zubair Ahmed stood as a towering figure, a journalist whose words illuminated the shadows and gave voice to the unheard. His untimely passing on July 7, 2022, left an indelible void in the hearts of islanders and the journalistic community. As the editor of The Light of Andamans and a contributor to platforms like Being Islander, Zubair was more than a chronicler of events; he was a beacon of truth, a defender of justice, and a storyteller who wove the essence of the Andamans into his work. Today, in 2025, as the islands continue to navigate the complexities of development, identity, and preservation, Zubair’s legacy remains a guiding light, inspiring a new generation to carry forward his mission. Zubair Ahmed’s journalism was rooted in a profound love for the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Through The Light of Andamans, a news magazine he revived alongside his mentor Govind Raju, and later through his independ...

GB Pant : The Hospital that Carries Five Lakh Heartbeats

There is a famous saying in India: “Health is wealth.” In Andaman & Nicobar Islands, however, the updated government version seems to be: “Tourism is wealth… health can wait.” Welcome to GB Pant Hospital, Port Blair - the grand old warrior of the islands. Established in 1963, this hospital has spent nearly 63 years carrying the healthcare burden of almost five lakh islanders. One building, one overburdened system, one exhausted backbone trying to keep an entire archipelago alive. And honestly, if walls could speak, the walls of GB Pant Hospital would probably say: “Bhai, mujhe bhi retirement do.” The hospital stands today not merely as a healthcare institution, but as a living archaeological monument. Some sections look less like a modern medical facility and more like a government structure preserved from the black-and-white Doordarshan era. Paint peeling, ageing infrastructure, leaking corners, rusted frames, yet inside these tired walls, doctors continue performing miracles ever...

“Suno Andamanwalo! Andaman Ban Raha Hai Maldives… Bas Bijli Aur Paani Chor Do”

 Welcome to the picturesque Andaman & Nicobar Islands, where the beaches shine, the coconuts fall in rhythm, tourists float in luxury, and the locals? Well, they’re navigating potholes, blackout schedules, and tanker water with Olympic-level patience. In this exotic dreamland, the administration has found its new obsession: not electricity, not hospitals, not bridges, but eco-resorts. Yes, because nothing screams “inclusive development” like a ₹391 crore luxury retreat at Long Island while the common man sits in darkness, fanning mosquitoes with old election pamphlets. As per the official vision, eco-resorts will bloom at Smith Island, Shaheed Dweep, Long Island, Aves Island, and Sri Vijaya Puram. With budgets ranging from ₹60 crore to nearly ₹400 crore, these will feature five-star rooms, wellness spas, water villas, and if luck permits uninterrupted power. Meanwhile, back in the real Andamans, the NVVN Chatham power plant has been shut down for “upgradation,” resulting in sch...